India’s Crypto Regulation Gap: A Growing Challenge for Law Enforcement

India’s cryptocurrency market is expanding rapidly, driven by technological innovation and increasing public interest. According to the 2024 Chainalysis Geography of Cryptocurrency report, India leads the world in crypto adoption and has become a major hub for blockchain startups and digital asset trading. However, this rapid growth has also exposed a critical issue—the lack of a comprehensive regulatory framework. The absence of clear regulations has made it difficult for law enforcement agencies (LEAs) to monitor and act against crypto-related crimes, creating opportunities for illegal activities while leaving legitimate investors in a state of legal uncertainty.

Surge in Crypto Crimes and Law Enforcement Struggles

Globally, cryptocurrency-related crimes are on the rise. Chainalysis reports that illicit crypto transactions amounted to approximately $46.1 billion in 2023, increasing to over $51 billion in 2024. In India, this risk is even more pronounced due to the high number of crypto users combined with limited regulatory oversight. The inclusion of crypto businesses under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) in March 2023 was a step forward, but major challenges remain. Tracking suspicious transactions and identifying perpetrators remains a complex task, especially when criminals operate across multiple states or international borders.

India’s federal structure further complicates law enforcement efforts. Policing and law enforcement fall under state governments, leading to disparities in cybercrime investigation capabilities across states. While some technologically advanced police departments have access to modern cybercrime tools, many states lack the necessary expertise and resources. Criminals exploit this inconsistency by operating in states with weaker enforcement, making it even harder to take decisive action.

Regulatory Uncertainty Hurts Both Businesses and Investors

The lack of regulatory clarity is not just benefiting criminals but also creating obstacles for legitimate crypto businesses. Many startups and exchanges face sudden account freezes or prolonged legal scrutiny due to the absence of clear guidelines for financial institutions. Meanwhile, at the national level, the government’s crypto policy appears largely focused on revenue collection, exemplified by the 30% tax on crypto gains and 1% TDS on transactions. These heavy tax policies have driven many Indian traders to foreign platforms, making it even harder for authorities to track cross-border crypto crimes.

How Other Countries Are Addressing Crypto Regulation

Several countries have taken concrete steps to regulate the crypto industry. The European Union has implemented the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, ensuring consumer protection, market transparency, and anti-money laundering measures. In the United States, agencies like the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) oversee different aspects of the crypto market, creating a structured regulatory environment. Nations like Brazil and Dubai have also introduced dedicated regulatory bodies to manage crypto-related activities. In contrast, India has yet to designate a single authority responsible for overseeing virtual digital assets (VDAs).

The Need for a Stronger Regulatory Framework

The evolving nature of crypto technology continues to pose challenges for law enforcement. Decentralized finance (DeFi), stablecoins, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have disrupted traditional financial oversight, making it harder for authorities to track illicit activities. A 2022 CipherTrace report found that over 80% of crypto theft cases were linked to DeFi hacks. In India, criminals use techniques like “chain-hopping” and privacy-enhancing tools to evade detection, making enforcement efforts even more difficult.

Several high-profile crypto crimes in India highlight these challenges. The 2022 WazirX hack led to losses exceeding $230 million after cybercriminals compromised private keys. In another case, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) seized ₹190 million in assets linked to illegal loan apps, but enforcement actions remain fragmented and slow.

To address these growing challenges, India urgently needs a comprehensive regulatory framework. The central government should establish a dedicated crypto regulatory agency to create uniform guidelines for all states. Improved data-sharing mechanisms between states would enhance cybercrime enforcement, while investment in blockchain forensic tools and cybercrime training for law enforcement agencies would strengthen investigative capabilities. Encouraging public-private partnerships could help strike a balance between regulation and innovation, ensuring that the crypto industry grows responsibly.

If India wants to safeguard its rapidly expanding crypto economy and maintain public trust in digital assets, it must prioritize the development of a robust regulatory framework. A clear and effective policy will not only curb illicit activities but also foster innovation, helping India maintain its leadership in the global digital asset market while ensuring national security and economic stability. Now is the time for decisive action to create a safe, transparent, and sustainable crypto ecosystem.

Also read :-