The Birmingham City Council on Tuesday filed a Section 114 notice to halt all spending except on essential services – which will not cover statutory services Financial Crisis.
Birmingham, the United Kingdom’s second-largest city, has found itself in dire financial straits, leading to the declaration of a Section 114 notice. This notice effectively puts a halt to all non-essential spending, a move that has garnered significant attention due to the city’s soaring equal pay claims, which have reached a staggering 760 million euros ($954 million). Birmingham now anticipates a deficit of 87 million euros ($109 million) for the 2023-24 financial year, as reported by CNN.
Why is this happening?
The primary catalyst behind this fiscal crisis can be traced back to several interconnected factors that have plagued Birmingham for years. First and foremost, the city has grappled with a steady increase in social care demands, coupled with reductions in business rate incomes and the ever-rising inflation rate. Adding fuel to the fire, more than a decade ago, around 5,000 female council staff successfully won an equal pay case at an employment tribunal in 2010. They contended that they were unjustly denied bonuses that were traditionally offered to their male counterparts, as reported by the BBC.
Since that landmark tribunal decision, Birmingham City Council has had to allocate nearly 1.1 billion euros towards addressing equal pay claims, with this bill ballooning by 14 million euros each month. To make matters even worse, the city’s new IT system, provided by Oracle and designed to handle payments, data management, and background checks, has encountered significant problems. Initially budgeted at 19 million euros, delays of three years have driven the cost up to approximately 100 million euros.
The issuance of the Section 114 notice signifies Birmingham’s inability to shoulder its mounting financial liabilities and its incapacity to engage in any form of new spending. The city has faced criticism for continuing to host the Commonwealth Games in 2022 despite its fiscal woes.
Fiona Greenway, the council’s interim director of finance, disclosed that external auditors expressed concerns regarding the funds allocated for equal pay claims and the city’s ability to generate additional income to offset the substantial projected deficit for the year. The UK government, led by Rishi Sunak, has been actively engaged with Birmingham to addressRishi Sunak these issues. They’ve expressed apprehensions regarding the city’s governance arrangements and have sought assurances from the council’s leader concerning the responsible use of taxpayers’ money.
So, what lies ahead for Birmingham? While city councils cannot formally declare bankruptcy due to their obligation to provide essential statutory services like education, social care, waste collection, and housing services, Birmingham City Council has committed to putting a halt to all new spending, with the exception of safeguarding vulnerable populations and essential statutory services.
What will happen now?
John Cotton, the council leader, has stressed the importance of safeguarding vital services while acknowledging the necessity of making difficult and robust decisions to rectify the city’s precarious financial situation. The upcoming 2026 European Championships scheduled to be held in Birmingham further complicate matters.
Political dimensions are also at play, as the Birmingham council is governed by the Labour Party. This has drawn criticism from Conservatives who argue that the council has failed to address equal pay issues with the urgency required. In response, Sharon Thompson, the council’s deputy leader, has placed blame on successive Conservative governments for stripping away 1 billion euros in funding.
In July, Prime Minister Sunak ruled out a bailout for Birmingham City Council, asserting that it was not the government’s role to rescue the council from financial mismanagement.
The council is set to convene an emergency meeting later this month, where further discussions with the government will be held to chart a way forward in this challenging financial landscape.